Utah Court of Appeals: Employee Caught on Camera Taking a Customer’s Wallet had no Actionable Claim against Employer

The Utah Court of Appeals upheld a trial court’s summary judgment dismissal of a former employee’s claim against Target for breach of contract, intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, and defamation.  In a twenty page opinion, the court said that the employee, who had been caught on camera taking a customer’s wallet, had no […]

Read More

Utah Employment Cases for the week of August 11

The following cases affecting Utah employment law were released during the week of August 11th:Utah Court of Appeals: Prows v. Labor Commission (Utah Ct. App., August 14, 2014) (declining, on the bases of what the definition of “is” is, to disturb refusal to find gainfully employed petitioner permanently and totally disabled)Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals: […]

Read More

The Strange Case of Blauer and the DWS: A Question of Sovereign Immunity … Sort of

BLAUER v. DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES  2014 UT App. 100 (Utah Ct. App., May 1, 2014) When [ironies] come, they come not single spies, but in battalions.                          — Paraphrasing Hamlet IV.v The Department of Workforce Services, charged with administering Utah employment law, fired Blauer, its legal counsel, for rejecting its proposed accommodations to his […]

Read More

Tenth Circuit: Favoring a Paramour Not Necessarily Gender Discrimination

In Clark v. Cache Valley Electric Co. (10th Cir., July 25, 2014), the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a federal district court had properly dismissed a gender discrimination and retaliation claim brought by a Utah employee of Cache Valley Electric.  The employee claimed that a supervisor was favoring an employee who had allegedly been […]

Read More

Tenth Circuit: Carbon County Properly Dismissed Benefits Administrator for Dragging Her Feet on her Own FMLA Paperwork

In a case decided today, Dalpiaz v. Carbon County, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Carbon County’s decision to discharge a benefits administrator when she “acted insubordinately by choosing to submit her FMLA forms at almost the literal last minute, more than seven weeks after the county made its first request for these forms […]

Read More

Utah Supreme Court: Private University’s Police Cadet was Public Employee Entitled to Immunity

In Mallory v. Brigham Young University, the Utah Supreme Court held that a police cadet employed by BYU was considered an employee for governmental immunity purposes.  The decision reversed a 2012 Utah Court of Appeals decision holding otherwise, and concluded that the plaintiff had no claim because he had failed to serve a notice of claim […]

Read More

Utah Supreme Court Rejects Department of Workforce Service’s Interpretation of Statute

In a case decided on June 20, 2014, Dorsey v. DWS, 2014 UT 22, the Utah Supreme Court held that the Department of Workforce Services (DWS) had “erroneously interpreted” a statutory provision to ban seasonal employees who receive work-search deferrals from leaving the country.  As in many cases as discussed in an earlier post, the unemployment […]

Read More

Tenth Circuit: Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act Tolls the Statute of Limitations on Claims for Discriminatory Compensation

In Almond v. Unified School District #501, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, which was enacted in 2009, does not extend the statute of limitations on all discrimination claims every time a person receives a paycheck.  Rather, the Tenth Circuit concluded it applies to extend the statute […]

Read More