United States Supreme Court Agrees that Pension Plan that Pays Benefits based on Unequal Credits Given to Pregnant Women is Lawful.

On Monday, May 18, the United States Supreme Court ruled that a pension plan that paid out benefits to pension receipients based upon calculations that did not equally credit women who had taken pregnancy leave prior to the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA) were not presently violating the Pregnancy Discrimination Act. The Court explained in its […]

Read More

New Whistleblower Protections!

The Stimulus Package that was enacted in February, otherwise called the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, provides sweeping whistleblower protections to any employee of an employer who receives any stimulus money. The protections found in section 1553 of the Act prohibit any demotion, discharge, or other discrimination of an employee when he or […]

Read More

Failure to Update Employment Application Process Could Be Big Problem for Utah Employers.

The new Employment Selection Procedures Act became effective yesterday, May 12, 2009. As discussed in an earlier post, the Act requires an employer to “maintain a specific policy regarding the retention, disposition, access, and confidentiality of information” gathered in the “initial selection process,” i.e, the application process. In fact, the new law requires that an […]

Read More

Utah Statute Reducing Workers Compensation Benefits for Social Security Retirement Benefits Found Unconstitutional.

In Merrill v. Utah Labor Commission, the Utah Supreme Court ruled that the Utah Workers Compensation statutory provision that requires the reduction of workers compensation benefits by 50% of the Social Security retirement benefits received by an injured worker was unconstitutional under the “uniform operations of law” clause or article I, section 24 of the […]

Read More

Utah’s Public Employers Are Not Required to Withhold Voluntary Political Contributions from Their Employees’ Paychecks

In Utah Education Association v. Shurtleff, the Tenth Circuit vacated its prior decision and upheld Utah’s Voluntary Contributions Act, which provides that a public employer cannot withhold from its employees’ paychecks any voluntary political contributions, including contributions to unions. The Tenth Circuit initially agreed with the district court that the Act was unconstitutional because it […]

Read More

Be Careful When You Negotiate Severance Agreements!

In Creative Consumer Concepts, Inc. v. Kreisler, the Tenth Circuit—the federal court having jurisdiction over Utah—discussed several evidentiary matters arising out of a severance agreement gone bad. Creative Consumer Concepts, Inc., terminated the employment of one of its vice presidents in 2004. In terminating the relationship, the company offered the vice president a severance agreement. […]

Read More

Does Relatively Minor Sexually Harassing Behavior Trigger an Employee’s Duty to Report the Conduct?

In a case decided on Thursday, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals—the appellate court having jurisdiction over Utah— upheld the dismissal of a complaint brought by a woman against the Colorado Department of Transportation for sexual harassment and retaliation she claimed occurred while she was working for the agency as an administrative assistant. In the […]

Read More