“Go Back to Mexico” Comments Evidence of National Origin Discrimination

The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals—the circuit having jurisdiction over Utah—held on March 19, 2009, in a case entitled Avila v. Jostens, Inc., that a supervisor’s statement to an employee that he “should get out of the country if he couldn’t speak English” at approximately the time the employee was fired was “circumstantial evidence of […]

Read More

May Employers Be Forced to Allow Employees to Store Weapons on Employer Property?

In Ramsey Winch Inc. v. Henry, the Tenth Circuit (the federal court having jurisdiction over Utah) ruled last week that a district court had erred when it held that a newly enacted Oklahoma statute making it a criminal offense for employers to prohibit employees from storing firearms in their vehicles on company parking lots was […]

Read More

When is Action by an Employer Harmful to the Point that It Dissuades a Reasonable Worker from Complaining?

The Tenth Circuit (the federal appeals court having jurisdiction over Utah) decided last week that three employees did not have a retaliation claim when they were unable to establish that the alleged actions taken against them by the Wichita Police Department would not dissuade a reasonable worker from making a charge of discrimination. In the […]

Read More

When Does an Employer Have to Give a 60-Day Notice Before Laying-Off Employees?

The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (WARN) requires certain employers to give 60 days advance notice of a mass lay off to its employees. WARN, however, does not require the notice in certain circumstances. The court having appellate jurisdiction over Utah, the Tenth Circuit, decided earlier this week in Gross v. Hale-Halsell Company, that […]

Read More

Employers May Be Liable for their Supervisors’ Misconduct Even When They Act Reasonably.

The Tenth Circuit decided in a case issued on January 12, 2009, that a Utah movie theater may be liable for its supervisor’s sexual assault of a subordinate even when (1) the theater acted reasonably under the circumstances , (2) the supervisor had no history of sexual harassment before the assault, and (3) the theater […]

Read More

Do Governmental Employees Have the Right to Comment on their Belief that the Agency by which they are Employed is Acting Outside its Authority?

The federal appellate court having jurisdiction over federal questions arising in Utah, the Tenth Circuit, issued a decision on January 8, 2009, explaining that an employee’s concern over the scope of an investigation was a matter of public concern. The court in Dixon v. Kirkpatrick held that, although an employee had raised an issue of […]

Read More

Does a Utah Governmental Employee Have a Right to Stay in Current Job Position?

The federal appellate court having jurisdiction over federal questions arising in Utah, the Tenth Circuit, issued a decision on January 6, 2009, delineating the scope of the rights that an employee employed by a governmental entity may have in staying in the same position that he or she has historically had. The case, Potts v. […]

Read More