Employee who Admitted Misconduct and that He had No Evidence of Discriminatory Intent Had No Discrimination Claim

In Hall v. Interstate Brands Corporation, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals—the federal appellate court having jurisdiction over Utah—recently ruled that a district court correctly dismissed an employee’s discrimination claim against his employer when the employee admitted that he had engaged in misconduct and conceded that there was no evidence other than his own personal […]

Read More

When is a Sarbanes-Oxley Retaliation Claim Timely?

In Rzepiennik v. Archstone-Smith, Inc., the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, the federal circuit having jurisdiction over Utah, considered the question of when a retaliation claim under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) is considered timely. The employee in the case contended that his employer had retaliated against him when he reported financial irregularities internally by terminating […]

Read More

New Whistleblower Protections!

The Stimulus Package that was enacted in February, otherwise called the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, provides sweeping whistleblower protections to any employee of an employer who receives any stimulus money. The protections found in section 1553 of the Act prohibit any demotion, discharge, or other discrimination of an employee when he or […]

Read More

Does Relatively Minor Sexually Harassing Behavior Trigger an Employee’s Duty to Report the Conduct?

In a case decided on Thursday, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals—the appellate court having jurisdiction over Utah— upheld the dismissal of a complaint brought by a woman against the Colorado Department of Transportation for sexual harassment and retaliation she claimed occurred while she was working for the agency as an administrative assistant. In the […]

Read More

“Go Back to Mexico” Comments Evidence of National Origin Discrimination

The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals—the circuit having jurisdiction over Utah—held on March 19, 2009, in a case entitled Avila v. Jostens, Inc., that a supervisor’s statement to an employee that he “should get out of the country if he couldn’t speak English” at approximately the time the employee was fired was “circumstantial evidence of […]

Read More

When is Action by an Employer Harmful to the Point that It Dissuades a Reasonable Worker from Complaining?

The Tenth Circuit (the federal appeals court having jurisdiction over Utah) decided last week that three employees did not have a retaliation claim when they were unable to establish that the alleged actions taken against them by the Wichita Police Department would not dissuade a reasonable worker from making a charge of discrimination. In the […]

Read More

Proposed Legislation: A Health Care Worker Can Sue for an Abusive Work Environment

The Utah State Legislature is considering whether to enact a measure that would make it illegal for health care facilities, agencies, or providers to subject their employees to abusive work environments or to retaliate against them for reporting abusive environments. The bill, House Bill 224, Health Care Provider Abusive Work Environment Prohibition Act, defines such […]

Read More

Employees Who Never File Complaints about Sexual Harassment But Merely Answer Questions are Protected from Retaliation.

The United States Supreme Court ruled in Crawford v. Metropolitan Government that a local government employee who answered questions posed to her about a human resource employee’s alleged sexual harassment was protected from retaliation even when she did not file her own complaint about his behavior. The questions came during an internal investigation being conducted […]

Read More